Companies facing unhappy customers and even lawsuits over their monetization choices is not new. In March, one player filed a $5 million lawsuit against Take-Two Interactive for what they consider to be over-the-top microtransactions in NBA 2K22. And Blizzard itself had to contend with another potential lawsuit in 2019, this time over the loot boxes offered in Overwatch. In March of this year, a California court decided that the case, which involved a minor, wouldn’t go to court.
RELATED: Hearthstone Players Are Unhappy With New $25 Diamond Card
Similarly, another case revolving around a child and monetization is now in the works. An Arizona man, Nathan Harris, has proposed a class-action lawsuit over the card pack microtransactions in Hearthstone. According to the complaint, Harris’ daughter spent over $300 from 2019 to 2021 buying card packs in the game, using her father’s linked credit and debit cards without his knowledge or consent. The lawsuit contends that the child did not understand the low odds of pulling good cards and did not know that the money spent was non-refundable. Furthermore, Harris states that his daughter “almost never received any valuable cards.”
The goal of Harris’ proposed class-action lawsuit is to allow any children who have ever purchased a Hearthstone card pack to join the complaint. Being minors, they should be entitled to a refund of any money spent. The absence of parental controls in the game and the lack of transparency in the actual odds of obtaining rare, powerful, or valuable cards are also a problem. Potentially, this could mean hundreds or even thousands of people joining the suit, which might prove a nuisance but could hardly hurt the gaming giant. A recently released financial report revealed that Activision Blizzard made $5.2 billion from microtransactions and DLC in 2021 alone.
Blizzard has already filed a response to Harris’ complaint and asked that the suit be moved from the California State Superior Court to a US district court. According to the company’s response, damages from the proposed class-action lawsuit could exceed $5 million, thereby justifying the change in venue.
Reimbursement to parents of children who spent large sums of money on loot boxes, card packs, or gacha mechanics is not unprecedented. In February 2022, Ling Cheng Mong was refunded the $20,000 his daughter spent on Genshin Impact microtransactions. This money was reimbursed by the bank that issued the credit card used to make the purchases over a six-week period.
Hearthstone is available on Mobile and PC.
MORE: Hearthstone: All New Cards Coming to Battlegrounds in ‘Rise of the Naga’ Update
Source: Polygon
